When you order a pumpkin spice latte or a caramel macchiato from Starbucks, you likely have a good grasp of the sugar content in those drinks.
However, what can you anticipate when you select a beverage that is touted as “sugar-free?”
This question is at the center of a proposed class-action lawsuit in the U.S. that alleges the coffee giant falsely marketed eight of its protein drinks as “sugar-free” when they actually contain between 13 and 21 grams of sugar per venti-sized serving, primarily from the naturally occurring sugars found in milk.
The lawsuit, submitted on Friday in a federal court in Seattle and reviewed by CBC News, accuses Starbucks of attempting to exploit “the protein trend” and the nutritional choices made by consumers.
“By labeling its drinks as ‘Sugar-Free,’ Starbucks asserts a specific, quantifiable, and verifiable claim about these products. Consumers depend on such assertions when deciding to buy these items,” the complaint states.
“The 21 grams of sugar found in a venti Sugar-Free Caramel Protein Matcha is approximately equivalent to five teaspoons of sugar. This is nearly as much sugar as found in a standard Kit Kat bar.”

A screenshot of an Instagram post by Starbucks from Oct. 23, 2025, promoting some protein drinks as sugar-free. (@Starbucks/Instagram)
A representative from Starbucks informed CBC News on Wednesday that they deem the lawsuit’s allegations to be without merit.
“Starbucks has always provided clear and consistent information regarding its protein beverages, sugar-free alternatives, customization options, and nutritional details … and we plan to defend ourselves robustly,” the spokesperson stated.
So, are these beverages truly sugar-free? Is the labeling deceptive? And does this apply only to the U.S. or also to Canada?
Let’s delve into the lawsuit and uncover what is known.
Which drinks are involved?
The lawsuit identifies eight protein drinks that Starbucks markets as sugar-free:
- Sugar-free vanilla protein latte.
- Sugar-free caramel protein latte.
- Sugar-free vanilla protein matcha.
- Sugar-free caramel protein matcha.
- Iced sugar-free vanilla protein latte.
- Iced sugar-free caramel protein latte.
- Iced sugar-free vanilla protein matcha.
- Iced sugar-free caramel protein matcha.
All these items are available on both U.S. and Starbucks Canada websites under the “protein beverages” category. Although the eight drinks are categorized under a “no added sugar options” section, each is currently labeled with “sugar-free” in its name.
Starbucks introduced these beverages in September 2025, referencing data that indicates “71 percent of Canadian consumers are seeking to increase their protein intake.” In a press release at the time, Starbucks emphasized that its new protein drinks would be “offered unsweetened or sugar-free and are intended to assist customers looking to enhance their protein consumption.”
Are they truly sugar-free?
No, each drink does contain sugar — from 13 to 21 grams per venti-sized serving. At the upper end, that’s comparable to the amount of sugar found in a KitKat or Coffee Crisp candy bar, according to Health Canada.
When you navigate through the individual drinks on the company’s website, Starbucks provides nutritional information for each “sugar-free” protein beverage, detailing the grams of sugar by serving size. For example, a venti iced sugar-free vanilla protein latte is listed to contain 13 grams of sugar, while a venti sugar-free caramel protein matcha has 21 grams of sugar.
As highlighted in the lawsuit, “the sugar-free products all include milk, which contains lactose, a naturally occurring sugar.”
-
Whey up: Protein powder prices soar as global demand grows
-
Is it unprofessional to bring iced coffee to a job interview? Gen Z is being dragged for it
If it’s natural sugar, what’s the problem?
The crux of the issue lies not in the source of the sugar, but rather the “sugar-free” labeling, according to the lawsuit.
“Despite being aware that Sugar-Free products contain milk, which has lactose, and recognizing that lactose is a sugar, and even categorizing lactose as a sugar, Starbucks still chooses to label these drinks as ‘Sugar-Free,'” the lawsuit claims.
“Starbucks refers to these drinks as ‘Sugar-Free’ because it understands that consumers depend on such claims when making purchasing decisions.”
What consumer protection laws apply?
Under U.S. federal law, Starbucks is prohibited from using “sugar-free” to describe drinks that have more than 0.5 grams of sugar per 12-ounce serving, as stated in the complaint. This applies even if the sugar is derived from milk.
In Canada, similarly, for a product to be labeled as sugar-free, it must contain less than 0.5 grams of sugars per specified serving size, according to the Food and Drug Regulations.
In both nations, there is a distinction between labeling an item as “sugar-free,” as Starbucks has done with its protein drinks, and stating that it has “no added sugars,” which is how Starbucks also describes these beverages in nutritional details since it utilizes sugar-free syrups.
Lactose is recognized as a sugar in both Canada and the United States.
Food manufacturers often face lawsuits for alleged deceptive advertising, including numerous recent cases disputing “sugar-free” or “zero sugar” assertions for items containing a sugar substitute known as allulose.
What are the next steps?
The complaint demands unspecified damages for false advertising and breaches of various state consumer protection statutes. It also seeks to have the case recognized as a class action and requests a jury trial “for all issues that are triable.”
This lawsuit is brought on behalf of three individual consumers who purchased Starbucks’s sugar-free protein drinks in California, New York, and Washington.
Consumers may avoid sugar for a variety of reasons, including health concerns such as diabetes, as noted by Steve Berman, a co-founder and managing partner of the Seattle-based firm that initiated the lawsuit, in a press release.
“For many, such a significant mislabeling is crucial,” Berman remarked.
“Beverages with this much sugar are akin to consuming a candy bar.”


