Disliking a film can be just as fruitful, and perhaps even more amusing, than enjoying it.
A movie that is excessively foolish, poorly conceived, or outright malicious can generate just as much material for contemplation and debate as one that is truly impactful. In both scenarios, there’s at least something worth engaging with.
This is why it is particularly disheartening to come across a film like The Social Reckoning. The sequel to The Social Network, written and directed by Aaron Sorkin, follows the remarkable Facebook origin story from 2010 that Sorkin penned and David Fincher directed. This new entry stands out as one of those rare, lamentable anti-art offerings.
It is a movie so lacking in originality and depth that it is hard to muster genuine contempt for it, even as it strives to present itself as perpetually significant. Overall, it is such a tiresome insult that it offers insufficient insight or perspective to even disagree with, let alone productively dislike.
Given its focus on the epidemic of social media and corporate-driven groupthink, it ironically exemplifies the very issue that Sorkin aims to critique: the overwhelming amount of low-quality, unengaging “content” flooding our feeds and For You pages.
However, this mishandling of promising source material comes from a cast and crew that includes some of the most intriguing talents currently active.
The Social Reckoning chronicles Facebook’s era of unending expansion and claims to be a critical look at one of the three tech overlords of the digital age. (The other two are portrayed in Alex Gibney’s documentary Musk, set for an October 16 release in Canada, and Luca Guadagnino’s critique of Sam Altman/OpenAI, Artificial, which recently debuted to enthusiastic reviews at the New York Film Festival.)
The underlying pitch suggests that this is a sharp and relevant piece that will enlighten viewers and disrupt the status quo. But instead of the expected Spotlight, we have The Bear‘s Jeremy Allen White portraying Wall Street Journal reporter Jeff Horwitz, who works for a struggling publication trying to keep readers from abandoning them for social media. Meanwhile, Anora‘s Mikey Madison plays Frances Haugen, a disillusioned product manager on Facebook’s civic misinformation team.
Unsurprisingly, the two quickly connect and begin to uncover and reveal a hidden pattern of misconduct known as MSI (Meaningful Social Interactions), which has destabilized governments, dulled minds, and undermined the very essence of truth. Once again, what’s new?
At the same time, Succession’s Jeremy Strong takes on the role of Mark Zuckerberg, who is depicted as experiencing a significant decline in reputation, both within the narrative and in his cinematic portrayals.
In this portrayal, Zuckerberg is preparing for a hearing regarding his company’s role in undermining liberal democracy and the mental well-being of children worldwide.
In contrast to Jesse Eisenberg’s complex and engaging performance, which garnered him an Oscar nomination, this version of Zuckerberg appears less inspired and poorly developed compared to the Metaverse he envisioned.
If it weren’t for the flamboyant way Strong showcases the famously peculiar traits of a man who once had to publicly deny being a lizard, he would be nearly irrelevant to the storyline.

Mikey Madison, left, and Jeremy Allen White star in The Social Reckoning. (Leah Gallo/Sony Pictures/The Associated Press)
Beyond the unnervingly controlled behavior of a socially awkward figure and a hairstyle reminiscent of Fargo‘s Ole Munch mixed with Starburst’s Berries and Cream man, this version of Zuckerberg remains largely in the shadows.
Zuckerberg’s motivations gave the original film its unique and compelling character study. This time, however, we receive nearly nothing from the character, who instead lurks in the background, occasionally reminding us of his presence, yet proving that he has minimal impact on the unfolding events.
This holds true for the mundane, uniformly dull, and unimaginably cliché storyline at hand.
Sorkin’s portrayal of Zuckerberg functions more as a cheap marketing ploy, intended to entice audiences into watching the beleaguered yet captivated reporter Horwitz lead the determined, good-hearted Haugen against the powerful figure behind the scenes. It resembles an amateur screenwriter’s interpretation of The Client, albeit with more technology.
This predicament is not entirely Strong’s fault. From his endlessly tragic and committed performance as Kendall Roy to his captivating role as Trump’s fixer Roy Cohn in The Apprentice, we recognize that if there were any substantial narrative to explore, he would have unearthed it.
Rather, responsibility lies with Sorkin. For those who already have a disdain for the West Wing and Moneyball writer’s rapid, stylized dialogue and contrived situations, this may come as no surprise. However, even for those who appreciate Sorkin’s heightened reality, The Social Reckoning ultimately disappoints.
-
As The Social Reckoning hits theatres, Facebook whistleblower says the fight to rein in Big Tech continues
-
REVIEW
Tom Cruise is fantastic in Digger. You might hate it
What we are left with is a clumsy and overly sentimental narrative that somehow both exploits and overlooks its relevant and timely issues. It’s a wandering, self-indulgent mix of journalistic clichés that leads to White and Madison referencing superior journalism films in their dialogue.
The film culminates in a conclusion that is so shockingly cliché that it almost seems as if Sorkin were intentionally parodying the sentimental text-on-screen ending of Stand By Me.
Yet the most egregious aspect of The Social Reckoning is not these shortcomings; it is the overwhelming absence of risk, specificity, or purpose. The film’s entire duration appears to serve merely as a filler. It’s disheartening to see Sorkin—an Academy and Emmy award-winning writer—create something so completely bland that it hardly warrants animosity.
This comparison is unfavorable: While The Social Network used Facebook’s founding as a framework to delve into its creator’s psyche, Reckoning merely utilizes it as superficial background to present an inaccurate Wikipedia entry.
Beyond the contrasts with its predecessor, Reckoning is also disappointing due to its utter lack of anything to detest. Its general dullness and timidity are disappointing, and that, more than anything else, represents the worst fate for a work of art.

