On Wednesday, when the NDP’s arms-control legislation aimed at eliminating mostly permit-free military exports from Canada to the U.S. is scheduled for a vote, it may receive backing from over a dozen Liberal MPs.
If this occurs, it would represent the first instance of some members within the Liberal caucus diverging from the government’s stance on legislation since Prime Minister Mark Carney took office.
“Based on my observations, I believe there could be anywhere from nine to 16 Liberal MPs in favor of the bill,” stated Jenny Kwan, the NDP’s primary advocate for the bill, during a press briefing on Tuesday.
Two Liberal MPs, who requested anonymity due to the confidential nature of caucus discussions, confirmed that this estimate is indeed accurate.
To date, four Liberal members have publicly endorsed Bill C-233, which the NDP refers to as the No More Loopholes Act.
This proposed law would establish export regulations on arms and munitions sent to the U.S., mirroring the controls that are already in place for most other nations.
The NDP argues that Canadian arms shipped to the U.S. often end up in other countries, despite the Canadian government not exporting directly to those nations, with Sudan and Israel cited as examples.

Liberal MP Salma Zahid from Scarborough Centre is among the four Liberal MPs publicly supporting Kwan’s proposal. (Adrian Wyld/The Canadian Press)
During a parliamentary discussion on Monday, Liberal MP Salma Zahid remarked that the bill “is about ensuring Canada meets its international responsibilities and that our industries act responsibly within the global defense trade.”
“This legislation is not against the industry or Canada’s defense sector; rather, it opposes complicity in violence against civilians,” she added.
Other Liberal supporters include Nathaniel Erskine-Smith, Fares Al Soud, and Aslam Rana.
Last month, CBC News reported that Canada’s Crown corporation responsible for international arms sales had signaled to former international trade minister Dominic LeBlanc regarding U.S.-bound artillery propellants, which were partly intended for Israel, in March 2025.
This was over a year after the Canadian government had announced it would cease issuing permits for exports to Israel, citing concerns related to the Gaza conflict.
Activist organizations have also released a report claiming that hundreds of shipments have been sent from the U.S. to Israel. CBC News has independently tracked some of these shipments that originated in Canada.
Kwan indicates willingness for amendments
Kwan mentioned that she remains open to modifications to the private member’s bill but has yet to receive any specific proposals from Liberal MPs, aside from suggestions to eliminate references to the U.S.
The government maintains that the current exemption for the U.S. is not a loophole but a strategic decision aimed at enhancing defense integration with a crucial ally.

Should more than a dozen Liberal MPs align with the NDP as anticipated, it would be the first occasion since Prime Minister Mark Carney’s rise to power that members of his caucus have diverged from the government’s legislative stance. (Spencer Colby/The Canadian Press)
During Monday’s debate, Karim Bardeesy, parliamentary secretary to Industry Minister Mélanie Joly, stated that the bill would “restrict Canadian sovereignty during a time of significant conflict, without making any substantial difference regarding the conflicts that concern supporters of the bill.”
He further asserted that the bill would not close a loophole but would “undermine a vital defense and trade relationship with a NATO ally.”
Representing the Conservative Party, MP Ziad Aboultaif stated that the “bill attempts to impose Canadian foreign policy on our closest ally, while those in our defense industry would bear the cost.”
He warned that the legislation would create complications in the Canada-U.S. relationship and jeopardize Canadian jobs.
-
Crown corp. alerted minister’s office about U.S. artillery ammunition sale connected to Israel
-
Analysis
Build it here or buy it there? Canada’s defence plan meets Trump’s new arms agenda
The Bloc Québécois also expressed concerns. Bloc MP Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe mentioned that while the bill is well-intentioned, it is overly broad and could harm industries already impacted by American tariffs.
He also indicated that the U.S. might simply choose not to cooperate.
“The notion that the United States would begin seeking Canada’s approval to ship small arms and light weapons is unrealistic,” he stated.
When asked by CBC News whether the government plans to allow a free vote among members on Wednesday, House leader Steven MacKinnon’s office did not provide a response.
