A landmark church from New Brunswick that was sold in the late 1990s has found a new purpose in the vibrant arts district of Oklahoma City. The Old Trinity Church, constructed in 1842 as the sole Anglican church in Blackville, N.B., has been rejuvenated by new owner Ernesto Sanchez into an art studio in Oklahoma City’s bustling arts area.
Shirley Underhill, one of the last individuals baptized in the church, shared that efforts were made to preserve the historic church as a memorial, but financial constraints hindered the preservation. However, seeing the church come to life again brought joy to Underhill, who had been involved with the Old Trinity Church for over four decades and partook in its restoration post its deconsecration, sale, and relocation.
The site now serves as a memorial with a monument honoring past church ministers and acts as a burial ground for cremated individuals, as noted by Underhill. The church had been a cherished venue for weddings in the community, hosting elaborate ceremonies filled with flowers and attended by many, reminisced former Blackville resident David Underhill.
Following its deconsecration, the church was acquired by an individual from Oklahoma City, who eventually transformed it into an art studio in the Paseo Art District. The church’s journey to its new location involved disassembly and transportation on two trucks in late 2000, during which David Underhill salvaged the church organ as a keepsake.
The church’s evolution in Oklahoma City saw it transition through various roles, including an art studio, wedding venue, private residence, and back to an art studio. Throughout these changes, a plaque commemorating its New Brunswick roots remained present, underscoring its rich heritage.
Recently sold by realtor Britta Thrift, the property underwent several renovations over the years, presenting a unique challenge in pricing. The church’s distinct history and charm garnered significant interest, with many locals having personal connections to the site through various events like weddings and celebrations.
The latest owners, artists Lin and Ernesto Sanchez, envision the space as Ernesto’s art studio, emphasizing its serene ambiance and natural light conducive to creativity. They plan to welcome visitors by appointment and on designated walk-in days, ensuring the historic church remains accessible to those wishing to experience its legacy. The couple expressed a sense of responsibility and commitment to preserving the church’s heritage for future generations.